Buttermilk Bakeshop

Dessert Shops in Brooklyn, New York

4.8 (853)

Category	Dessert Shops · Cake shop
Address	264 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Area	Brooklyn, New York
Phone	(347) 987-3941
Google rating	4.8 (853)

Hours

Monday	Closed
Tuesday	11 am–6 pm
Wednesday	11 am–6 pm
Thursday	11 am–6 pm
Friday	11 am–8 pm
Saturday	11 am–8 pm
Sunday	11 am–6 pm

About Buttermilk Bakeshop

Custom wedding cakes, birthday cakes, baby shower and bridal shower cakes, cookies, cupcakes, brownies, cake pops, and pies. Owned and operated by Katy Kinch.

Located at 264 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, Buttermilk Bakeshop operates as a dessert shop serving Brooklyn in New York. This page gathers the practical details people usually look for before visiting: where it is, how to reach it, when it opens and how customers rate it. Besides its main category, the business also describes itself as cake shop, so it may cover more than the name suggests.

American bakeries range from wholesale operations that supply restaurants to neighborhood shops that sell bread, pastries, cookies and cakes over the counter, and many of them also pour coffee. Bagel shops boil and bake on site and sell out of favorite flavors by late morning; donut shops open before dawn and are often family-run; patisseries and cake studios take custom orders for weddings and birthdays and usually need one to two weeks' notice. Ice cream parlors, gelato shops and frozen yogurt bars are seasonal in the northern states and year-round in the South and on the West Coast. Prices are posted per item, by the dozen or by the pound, and most shops now take cards and mobile payment.

Hours are published for 6 days a week. Typical hours are 11 am–6 pm. It is closed on Monday. Hours in the United States do change around federal holidays and long weekends, so a quick call before a special trip is sensible. The listed phone number is (347) 987-3941. Many businesses also reply to text messages on the same number if it is a cell phone. Its website is buttermilkbakeshop.com, where you may find menus, price lists or booking options.

On Google it holds a rating of 4.8 out of 5 from 853 reviews, which is a strong result for a dessert shop in Brooklyn and suggests consistent service.

Brooklyn is in New York, in the Northeast, where four distinct seasons shape local life: hot humid summers, snowy winters that can close businesses for a day, and a dense pattern of towns where walking, transit and street parking all matter. US addresses list the street number and name, then the city, state abbreviation and ZIP code, and Brooklyn follows the same pattern; a suite or apartment number such as Ste 200 refers to a unit inside the building. The map link on this page shows the exact spot.

See the other dessert shops in Brooklyn listed below to compare ratings, hours and locations before you decide. If you own or manage Buttermilk Bakeshop, you can claim this listing to correct details, add photos and a description, and receive a verified badge. Everyone else can help by leaving an honest review on Google after a visit.

Is this your business? Claim this listing to update details, add photos and get a verified badge; every verified claim gives $1 to charity. Want more customers? Feature it at the top of dessert shops in Brooklyn.

Latest Google reviews

The 5 most recent reviews shown on Google Maps. Reviews belong to their authors; read all of them on Google.

Dominique Pamphile 2 months ago

Buttermilk, you truly excelled! The cake design turned out just as I envisioned it, elegant and classy. I am truly impressed and completely satisfied. My wife adored the creation and the chocolate flavor. The cake was moist and bursting with flavor. Simply outstanding! The birthday girl loved it. I'll for sure be a returning customer.

Alexandra McCoy 2 months ago

I got married back in May in Brooklyn for our destination wedding, and we absolutely loved our wedding cake! From the very beginning, the communication and attention to detail were outstanding. Planning a wedding from out of town can be stressful, but they made the entire process so easy and took such great care of us every step of the way. The moment I walked into the room and saw our cake, it made me smile. It was everything I hoped it would be and fit our wedding day perfectly. Not only was it beautiful, but it tasted amazing too. We received so many compliments from our guests on both the look and the taste. Everyone was absolutely obsessed! Thank you for putting so much care and talent into creating such a special part of our wedding day. We couldn’t have been happier with our cake and would recommend you to anyone looking for a beautiful and delicious wedding cake!

CWZY 2 months ago

Not my first cake from Buttermilk and they have not missed yet. This one was for a baby shower and it might be my favorite thing about the entire day - guests kept commenting on it before we even cut it, and it's the detail I keep thinking back on. Planning was smooth and responsive. They shared a rendering ahead of time, which set my expectations high, and the actual cake blew past them. It was as beautiful as anything I've seen from a bakery, and the taste matched. Delivery arrived right on time and the cake held perfectly for a few hours in the party room, no refrigeration needed. Zero stress on a morning that had plenty of moving parts, and a cake that made the whole event feel special. Thank you!

Dae 2 months ago

I’ve been going to Buttermilk Bakeshop since 2018, possibly even earlier, and they have never disappointed! They’ve made my children’s birthday cakes since 2021, and every single time, they execute my vision perfectly and never miss a detail. The team is always so friendly, professional, and talented. They are truly the absolute best! My kids look forward to their birthdays and class parties for the cake and desserts !

Annie Thermidor Grimes 2 months ago

I was hosting a surprise event for my husband in the neighborhood and thankfully found this bakery. I love how their website already featured specific custom cakes. I chose the sneaker box cake which was perfect. The interaction was the place via their message box was seamless as I work at night. I changed my mind from pick up to delivery couple days before and that was handled smoothly. The cake came out perfect and was that talk of the party. Would definitely purchase from this place again.

All reviews on Google ↗

Frequently asked questions

Where is Buttermilk Bakeshop located?

Buttermilk Bakeshop is at 264 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, in Brooklyn, New York. Use the “Open in Google Maps” button on this page for directions.

What kind of business is Buttermilk Bakeshop?

Buttermilk Bakeshop is listed as a dessert shop and is also tagged on Google as cake shop.

What are the hours of Buttermilk Bakeshop?

Published hours are Monday: Closed; Tuesday: 11 am–6 pm; Wednesday: 11 am–6 pm; Thursday: 11 am–6 pm; Friday: 11 am–8 pm; Saturday: 11 am–8 pm; Sunday: 11 am–6 pm. It is closed on Monday. Hours can change on holidays, so call before a special trip.

Is Buttermilk Bakeshop open on Sunday?

Yes, on Sunday it is open 11 am–6 pm.

What is the phone number of Buttermilk Bakeshop?

You can call Buttermilk Bakeshop at (347) 987-3941.

How is Buttermilk Bakeshop rated on Google?

Buttermilk Bakeshop has a Google rating of 4.8 out of 5 from 853 reviews.

Does Buttermilk Bakeshop have a website?

Yes, the website of Buttermilk Bakeshop is buttermilkbakeshop.com (linked on this page).